Boot styles

[Rob__]

I couldnt find the thread for this (I'm sure one exists) so wanted to start this discussion.

Recently a co-worker had a motorcycle accident (I'm informed the driver "didn't see him" (8:30pm) and tried to shoot through the "gap" in cars). The accident details I've heard are second and third hand so are most likely skewed. His worst injury is the loss of his left leg below the knee. I was told yesterday that his boot (low style laceup) had caught on the bumper of the vehicle and "gloved" his foot off.

I wear Oxtar Matrix 2s and one of his friends made the comment it would slip off if pulled that hard. (Yes, I did put them on to the Fieldsheers that Al Lambs (http://stores.ebay.com/Al-Lambs-Dallas-Honda_Riding-Gear_BOOTS_W0QQcolZ4QQdirZ1QQfsubZ14723965QQftidZ2 QQtZkm) Honda has for sale on ebay $39 (none in my size EU48 rats!) I think that's a matter of where and if the boot catches and certainly hope it does, but here's the question:

What are your opinions on boot styles?

I had not considered the "catching" issue, but like a high smooth/clean boot with the inside zipper. This was because I wear them to work. I love the Oxtars and just wish they made a "steel toed" version with a harder sole.

[Styles]

What are your opinions on boot styles?



Yes, indeed . . . :D

But seriously, I'm not sure if "boot styles" designed to slip off makes real sense; in any accident, the variables are always infinite, so your story couldn't in all probability be invoked as a design principle.

It does, however, give one pause to think!

Meanwhile, I'm sticking with my loggers (http://www.st-owners.com/forums/showthread.php?p=375505#post375505).

Styles

[Gonzo]

As disturbing as that incident might be, I don't think it should have any bearing whatsoever in your selection of a boot. Think of fit, comfort, and intended use.

What are the weather extremes it will be expected to see? Do you plan to do a lot of walking in it? Are zippers or velcro desirable vs. laces or buckles?

Do you need a high boot to shed water? Thick soles for added reach to the street surface?

These things should overshadow any consideration of how fast a boot could be slid off, IMHO.

For myself, I have been using a steel-toed work boot, but now that they are worn out, I now use combat boots. Very roomy in the toe box and great ankle support. Neither one of those cost much, either.

[Capt_Gruuvy]

I think it is the same concept as the guy who had his head removed when his full face helmet caught on a stop sign. Unless that stop sign is part of a Stop Sign Jihad Sleeper Cell I think it's a freak thing.

I still wear full face helmets.

I wear jungle boots. It's just too flipping hot out here for anything more substantial.

Do what makes you feel the most comfortable ... that's my motto.

[militarydad]

I woud think there would be way more instances where you wouldn't want your boots to come off. JMHO

[oldtalljoe]

I couldnt find the thread for this (I'm sure one exists) so wanted to start this discussion.

Recently a co-worker had a motorcycle accident (I'm informed the driver "didn't see him" (8:30pm) and tried to shoot through the "gap" in cars). The accident details I've heard are second and third hand so are most likely skewed. His worst injury is the loss of his left leg below the knee. I was told yesterday that his boot (low style laceup) had caught on the bumper of the vehicle and "gloved" his foot off.

I wear Oxtar Matrix 2s and one of his friends made the comment it would slip off if pulled that hard. (Yes, I did put them on to the Fieldsheers that Al Lambs (http://stores.ebay.com/Al-Lambs-Dallas-Honda_Riding-Gear_BOOTS_W0QQcolZ4QQdirZ1QQfsubZ14723965QQftidZ2 QQtZkm) Honda has for sale on ebay $39 (none in my size EU48 rats!) I think that's a matter of where and if the boot catches and certainly hope it does, but here's the question:

What are your opinions on boot styles?

I had not considered the "catching" issue, but like a high smooth/clean boot with the inside zipper. This was because I wear them to work. I love the Oxtars and just wish they made a "steel toed" version with a harder sole.
Gee, I would have thought that anything that pulled hard enough to remove a foot would have broken the lace and that would have freed the foot from the awkward position.

Joe

[roginoz]

If I'm going to be gone a long time, I wear my Raichle hiking boots; GoreTex, fairly substantial, and I can walk in them all day. Good thick soles are more comfortable on the pegs. Fortunately, I don't have to worry about dress codes any longer.