Well, I was able to clean out the seal and get it to re-seat and stop leaking and I didn't remove that damn fork protector. Thanks for all of y'all's responses.
Just FYI, prior to creating this thread, I had done a quickie Sealmate cleaning without an actual Sealmate. I just took some plastic from the recycle pile and cut out something like it. It took out a lot of gunk but with that damn fork protector in the way I couldn't get the front real well. Turns out I didn't cut it wide enough to be able to handle the pushing. So this time I broke down and spent the $6 on a 3 cent piece of plastic that is actually called a Sealmate. It is wider and was easier to push through both seal surfaces. I had to pump on the forks/wipe oil off about 4-5 times but it eventually reset and stopped leaking. Took it for a 10 mile test run and no leaks.