Kind of a subjective opinion there. Curious... how do you evaluate, assess weight of points and score them to know they are better?
Wall thickness?
The MCL tip over bars are the same ones that are used on police STs. The police have very strict requirements on the equipment that they use on their units.
Strength of tubing?
See above. Nothing more to say. The MCL tip over bars also have an additional brace on the bars to make them really sturdy.
Grade of mounting hardware?
Looks good to me.
Compatibility with other accessories?
No problems that I have found. If you carry a passenger there are some issues. I don't carry a passenger so no problem for me.
Ease of installation?
Couldn't be easier, and I am terrible with a wrench.
Removal required for servicing bike?
No problem.
Interference with feet?
Yes, for the passenger. MCL sells passenger pegs that solve this problem.
Pillion comfort?
Great, with the available passenger pegs.
Durability of finish?
Powdercoated. Pretty tough stuff. If I should nick it I can get a spray can and touch it up.
Appearance?
This is pretty subjective, but I like the way they look. Since they are black they don't stand out much compared to the chrome Gold wing bars.