Helmets Shoei RF-1100 vs X-Eleven

Joined
Jan 1, 2008
Messages
18
Location
Huntsville, Alabama
Bike
2006 ST1300A
Ok,

If the two helmets were priced the same, which helmet would you choose and why?

The RF-1100 is the new version of the RF-1000. The X-eleven is the older version of the new X-twelve.

I have two RF-1000s and love them both. I'm just looking for a replacement since these are 5 years old.

Mike
 
http://www.webbikeworld.com/r2/shoei/x-eleven/
http://www.webbikeworld.com/r2/shoei/x-12/
http://www.webbikeworld.com/r2/shoei/rf-1100/

I've got the RF-1100 and love it -- so I am a bit prejudiced. But, reading the reviews -- if the two were priced the same (and they clearly are not) -- I would still go with the RF-1100. The conclusion of the wBW review says it all for me:

Conclusion

Much of what was said in the closing remarks for the RF-1100 review can be repeated here. The new Shoei X-12 is an excellent design loaded with high-quality features. It's not revolutionary, but an evolution of the X-Eleven, a very popular race helmet.

The lofty price of the X-Twelve does justify a very close critique. Let's face it: a lot of issues can be overlooked on a $100 helmet that become very annoying when that helmet costs nearly $800.00.

The problems we are experiencing with the ventilation in the X-12 are surprising, as is the increase in weight, both should have been improved over the X-11 in what is supposed to be a top-of-the-line race helmet.

But it's not just the price of the helmet per se. Many riders might be willing to pay a lofty premium for a helmet that offered some outstanding features that were head and shoulders above the competition. For example, super light weight or extremely low noise or superior venting; something -- anything -- to justify the cost.

But I just can't find a single superior area where I can honestly say that the X-12 completely outshines any other motorcycle helmet. Thus, the X-12 has let me down in a number of ways.

It's a beautifully made helmet, absolutely. But it's very difficult to justify spending 2-3 times more on the X-12 than for other helmets that are just as satisfying.

I wish I could say that the price of the X-12 is justified, but for me it isn't. I am interested in hearing opinions from other X-12 owners and learning more about their decision tree in choosing the X-Twelve over other helmets.

The x-eleven got better ratings than the x-12 -- but both are so much more expensive than the new RF-1100 (and have no real features to boast for that price difference) that I just couldn't justify the expense. JMHO
 
I have both the X-11 and the RF-1100. I love both....but for me, the RF-1100 won the day...simply because it's just a tad easier on the ears. (quiet) Both have great ventilation. The X-11 is smaller/more compact...but not by much. My experience shows the X-11 to be just a bit cooler...better air movement.
 
If I'm not mistaken, back when RF1000s and X11s were current one big difference was that the X11 had a removable liner while the 1000 did not. I believe that now the new RF1100 has the removable liner. FWIW, YMMV. :)

:06biker: :06biker: :06biker:
 
I think the X-11 would be a bit more noisy than the RF-1100. Of course you will get better ventilation on the X-11.

I just picked up the RF-1100 from Competition Accessories shipped to my door for 289.99.
 
The RF1100 isn't exactly a quiet helmet unless you leave the 2 front vents closed.
I think part of it is because the ear pockets are so deep.
 
Back
Top Bottom