Rider RSS Dainese Smart Air Airbag Vest Review

Joined
Dec 1, 2004
Messages
1,596
Age
62
Bike
'21 RT / '24 GSA
2026 Miles
000088
Dainese Smart Air Vest

In my First Gear column in the May 2024 issue, titled “Invest in Yourself,” I discussed the safety benefits of an airbag vest, which protects a rider’s torso and internal organs in the event of a crash. The most convenient ones are autonomous (rather than requiring a tether attached to the motorcycle) and employ “smart” technology that uses gyroscopes, accelerometers, and algorithms to determine when the system should deploy.

Rider staffers are required to wear an airbag vest in addition to a helmet and armored jacket, gloves, pants, and boots when riding test bikes. Most airbag vests cost about the same as a premium helmet, and every motorcyclist should wear one.

Over the past year, I’ve been wearing the Dainese Smart Air airbag vest, which is CE Level 2 certified for chest and back protection. The vest, which weighs about 3.5 lb, can be worn over or under a motorcycle jacket. The outer part of the vest is made of ventilated, breathable textile material with padded neoprene along the back. Inside the vest is the “triple-activation” airbag (it can be deployed three times before needing to be replaced), which covers the chest and back.

Dainese Smart Air Vest

Also inside the vest is the gas-generator cartridge and control module, which are contained within a rigid plastic compartment on the rider’s back (hence the padded neoprene). Because I wear the Smart Air vest under my jacket and the back of the vest is bulky, I remove my jacket’s back protector.

The Smart Air runs on a rechargeable battery claimed to last up to 12 hours, but in my experience lasts 8-10 hours. The necessary USB-C charging cable is not provided, so I bought one on Amazon for a few bucks, and I keep it and a wall socket block in the zippered front pocket. If I’m on a long ride, I’ll plug it in during lunch to ensure the battery has juice until I get to my destination.

Operating the Smart Air vest is easy. Put it on, zip it up, undo the red safety guard over the snap near the top of the zipper, and then snap the activation flap across the zipper. The safety guard prevents the vest from turning on by accident, which can happen with vests that use a magnetic closure for activation. On the upper left chest is a small D-air badge that buzzes and lights up when the vest is activated. The LED light pulses or flashes in various colors to indicate the system’s activation status (whether it is armed) and the battery’s charge status. You can also pair the Dainese D-air app with the vest to download over-the-air firmware updates, check battery status, and change settings.

Dainese Smart Air Vest

Should a deployment happen, the Road Shield gas-generator cartridge will need to be replaced. This can be done by the user, but you’ll need to buy a new cartridge ($139). I recommend buying an extra cartridge and carrying it with you so it can be replaced during a ride. An accidental deployment happened to me on a ride while wearing another brand’s airbag vest, and without an extra gas cartridge I had to ride home without the protection of an airbag.

Read all of Rider‘s apparel reviews here.

The Dainese Smart Air airbag vest retails for $749 and is available in three sizes: XS-SM, MD-LG, and XL-2XL.

Shop for Dainese Smart Air Airbag Vest

The post Dainese Smart Air Airbag Vest Review appeared first on Rider Magazine.

Continue reading...
 
I get irritated when I see reviews like this. The takeaway to me is the old-school air bag vests like the Hit-Air vest I wear are sooooo ooolllddd and something to be shunned. You just have to have the latest sensors and phone apps or your vest just isn't safe. And...you need to be able to wear it under your jacket to hide the fact that you're wearing one. You don't want anyone to think you're a safety dork, now do you?

One of the things not mentioned in the review is this Dainese vest if worn under your jacket needs a loose fitting jacket. Having just enough room to wear it under your current jacket probably is going to be a problem when it expands. I wonder if anyone has cracked ribs from having one of these deploy under a jacket. Something has to give, and I'll bet your jacket isn't it.

They make it sound like a tether is so incredibly bothersome. It's not...unless you're trying to sell a fancy system with "gyroscopes, accelerometers and algorithms". I think I've tried to walk away maybe 3-4 times over the years I've worn mine. It'll bring you up short...and without deploying. You learn quickly and it soon just becomes part of the getting on and off the bike routine.

I can't find it now, but I had a picture from when I had my accident in June 2024. I left the road at 70+ mph and accelerating. Came to an abrupt stop that had me going one way and my motorcycle pointing the other way about 35 feet away at least. My dash camera took pictures at 30 frames per second. That's fast when you think about it.

The first picture taken at 1/30th of a second after hitting the pole was of me about to land on the ground. My airbag vest was already deployed. It did its job perfectly.

One thing to think about is the protection this "smart" vest lacks. There's no protection for the neck or collarbone. No protection either for the tailbone.

Spare cartridges for the Dainese vest cost $139. The Hit-Air cartridges cost around $22-25.
The Dainese vest can be deployed only 3 times before needing to be replaced. The Hit-Air vest can be deployed repeatedly till you damage it too much.

But...and this is a big negative about the Hit-Air vest ...there's no app to check if your vest is working. And no batteries to charge in the middle of a long day ride.

An airbag vest is definitely worth it. I feel naked without mine. But be discerning about the marketing claims in the "reviews". I wonder how much money the magazines are getting for reviewing this vest? :unsure:

Chris
 
I wonder if this is the same vest that Lindsey Vonn was wearing and is required for all downhill ski racers.......
 
I get irritated when I see reviews like this. The takeaway to me is the old-school air bag vests like the Hit-Air vest I wear are sooooo ooolllddd and something to be shunned. You just have to have the latest sensors and phone apps or your vest just isn't safe. And...you need to be able to wear it under your jacket to hide the fact that you're wearing one. You don't want anyone to think you're a safety dork, now do you?
They make it sound like a tether is so incredibly bothersome.
The article I read had none of that.

You make some valid points about the Hit-Air bag. Maybe there a recent review of it you'd like to post.
 
If it is like their other products, the sizes run small. Which makes me wonder how large an "XL-2XL" is.

I would not wear an air vest under my jacket. If I had a jacket that had out-grown me maybe. But that's opposite of what usually happens. :biggrin:
 
The article I read had none of that.
It did if you picked up on the innuendos. Plus if you combine it with all the other "professional" reviews, you'll see the trends. I could be wrong ... I often am ...but I don't think there has been a positive review of tethered air bag vest in at least 5 years.

Chris
 
I wear a Held EVEST PRO airbag vest under my jacket. Held and in&motion have plenty of videos on their websites or YouTube showing how to measure your jacket with a tape measure so you know the vest has enough room to expand in case of deployment.

holm from Germany
 
I get irritated when I see reviews like this. The takeaway to me is the old-school air bag vests like the Hit-Air vest I wear are sooooo ooolllddd and something to be shunned. You just have to have the latest sensors and phone apps or your vest just isn't safe. And...you need to be able to wear it under your jacket to hide the fact that you're wearing one. You don't want anyone to think you're a safety dork, now do you?

One of the things not mentioned in the review is this Dainese vest if worn under your jacket needs a loose fitting jacket. Having just enough room to wear it under your current jacket probably is going to be a problem when it expands. I wonder if anyone has cracked ribs from having one of these deploy under a jacket. Something has to give, and I'll bet your jacket isn't it.

They make it sound like a tether is so incredibly bothersome. It's not...unless you're trying to sell a fancy system with "gyroscopes, accelerometers and algorithms". I think I've tried to walk away maybe 3-4 times over the years I've worn mine. It'll bring you up short...and without deploying. You learn quickly and it soon just becomes part of the getting on and off the bike routine.

I can't find it now, but I had a picture from when I had my accident in June 2024. I left the road at 70+ mph and accelerating. Came to an abrupt stop that had me going one way and my motorcycle pointing the other way about 35 feet away at least. My dash camera took pictures at 30 frames per second. That's fast when you think about it.

The first picture taken at 1/30th of a second after hitting the pole was of me about to land on the ground. My airbag vest was already deployed. It did its job perfectly.

One thing to think about is the protection this "smart" vest lacks. There's no protection for the neck or collarbone. No protection either for the tailbone.

Spare cartridges for the Dainese vest cost $139. The Hit-Air cartridges cost around $22-25.
The Dainese vest can be deployed only 3 times before needing to be replaced. The Hit-Air vest can be deployed repeatedly till you damage it too much.

But...and this is a big negative about the Hit-Air vest ...there's no app to check if your vest is working. And no batteries to charge in the middle of a long day ride.

An airbag vest is definitely worth it. I feel naked without mine. But be discerning about the marketing claims in the "reviews". I wonder how much money the magazines are getting for reviewing this vest? :unsure:

Chris
Not sure why you seem so offended. If you find the benefits of the Hit-Air outweigh the technology of the new-fangled ones, be confident that you have the better system. I have the hit air as well and it seems TO ME that I have a better for me system and I dont concern myself with anything they say. I dont see how they are running anything else down, just pointing out a different technology.
 
Back
Top Bottom