the service manual is vague on this point. For the removal procedure that bolt is the first to be loosened, but there's no "installation is the reverse of removal" line like sometimes appears, so there's an interpretation gap. With no other information, I'd assume "installation is the reverse of removal" to be the default, and therefore that bolt would get tightened last.
anything else in the manual that would contradict that?
I've thought about this quite a lot a good many years ago. The following few snippets are, I think, relevant to the decision to tighten the stopper bolt first.
First of all, the workshop manual does say to Torque the stopper bolt first - although I had to look that up. I don't remember reading it before either. This is taken from a purchased electonic version of the manual, but I checked ith my 2003.2004 printed version and it is exactly the same. Tighten the stopper bolt first.
But that doesn't address the reason.
I can only speculate - but I'm never satisfied with answers that I don't understand - but I think that the results of my ponderings are pretty robust.
- The hole in the caliper bracket is elongated. To allow for expansion of the caliper bracket due to the heat caused by brakes.
- The stopper bolt is to stop the caliper bracket from turning. When the brake pads grab hold of the brake disc, the easiest thing for the caliper to do is to hang on the the brake disc and spin around the axle. The stopper bolt stops the caliper bracket from doing this.
- The braking force is transmitted from the brake pads - the tab end of the pad's metal plate is pressed firmly agains a recess (which has the silver retainer clip) which is part of the caliper bracket. The caliper bracket is therefore subject to a lot of stress:
a) At the axle bolt - it is stopped from being pushed forward by the caiper grabbing hold of the brak disc.
b) At the stopper bolt which stops the caliper bracket from rotating.
- All screw threads have quite a bit of 'play' in them. The stopper bolt itself is screwed into a boss on the swing arm. A thick shaft protrudes from the other side of the boss and into the hole in the caliper bracket. The shaft is prevent from moving by the nature of the thread and by the heavy torque that is placed on it when tightening. This ensures that shaft threads are pulling tightly against the threads in the boss and that the head of the bolt is clamped agaisnt the face of the boss The oval shaped hole in the caliper bracket is set firmly at 90 degrees the shaft of the stopper bolt.
- The caliper itself is mounted using two relatively flimsy slider pins. These slide very loosely inside one hole in the caliper and one hole in the caliper bracket. The holes have a rubber bush to prevent water ingress. It should be possible to move the caliper in and out - towards and away from the brake disc - when the pads are not fitted. There will also be a little wiggle movement available. All the caliper has to do is to press the pads agains the brake disc. When it clamps the disc, the pads will try to slide forward. They cannot because they are pressing against the retainer clips in the bracket. The bracket cannot move forward because it is held in place with the axle. It cannot rotate becasue it is prevented by the stopper bolt. No strain is put on the caliper itself. It is all transferred to the stopper bolt.
Now armed with all of that information I have to do a bit of imagineering. The difference between whether the stopper bolt is tightened before or after the axle bolt.
The above is true if the stopper bolt is tightened first.
But if the axle is tightened first, there is a tendency for the caliper to want to rotate clockwise. It can't by very much - because the stopper bolt is in place - but it can a bit becasue it is looseley fitted and there is play in the threads. So when tightening the axle nut, the stopper bolt will tend to be lifted slightly - taking up some of the play in the thread. Continue tightening of the axle will lock this position in place. The stopper bolt at a slight angle.
Subsequently, tightening the stopper bolt will then be tightening against threads which are not in the correct position. It will not clamp the stopper bolt in position properly and the head will not be flush against the face of the boss. It will be clamped by the fact that the angle of the bolt is preventing it from moving any further. The slightly rotated caliper bracket is preventing it from tightening properly and it will be held at a slight angle.
So every time the brake is applied the bracket is presented with a stopper that is not at 90 degrees. So it isn't a stopper. It is now a deflector.
This twists the caliper bracket over time. So the slider pins are no longer at the correct angle. So every time the calipers want to move, they move at the wrong angle and the pads meet the discs at the wrong angle. The pressure forces them into place - there is leeway ont he lsider pins for the caliper to twist slightly - and braking is OK. But gradually the symptoms show. The recess in which the retainer clip sits, starts to wear. The pads start to wear unevenly and the pads do not move well against the slider pins - because the caliper is now working at an angle to, instead of parallel with, the slider pins.
The hole in the caliper bracket becomes patterned with a helical pattern (like the rifling in gun barrel - I believe as a result of being hammered and released by the caliper bracket on a bolt that isn't secured properly and not at 90 degrees. I guess also that the threads will be taking a bit of hammering as well.
(I cannot explain that behaviour convincingly enough - but there is something there that rings true. I remember as a kid being given the privelege of 'ringing the bell' for playtime at the end of morning lessons. It was a handbell and the clanger was on a chain.
I couldn't do it. The ball just whizzed around the inside of the bell chamber - round and round making a pathetic metallic scraping noise. I couldn't get it to hit the other side and 'clang' properly. Many years later I realised that I wasn't moving the bell up and down - so the clanger was not hitting the bell at right angles. It was deflected and just went round and round the inside of the bell.
So that behaviour with the sprial markings and the behaviour when something hits something else that isn't quite at right angles ? Well it sort of rings a bell.