I live about two hours north near the small town of Ramah, NM. Don’t bother coming HERE for pie, we only have a “greasy spoon joint”.
But, I was in Pie Town during Covid abt January, 2021. The original’Pie-O-Neer” cafe had closed due to government mandates and went out of business. But, an employee had taken the baton and run with it next door. Can’t remember the name of the new place, but they had a variety of pies that were good to excellent, along with burgers, etc.
IIRC, they were open limited hours and days last year, and when the pie is gone they close.
Check out the details before you make the trip from Arizona to be certain!