San Jose DUI suspect faces murder charge in fatal motorcycle crash

ST Gui

240Robert
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
1,082
Location
SF-Oakland CA
Bike
ST1300, 2010
San Jose DUI suspect with prior conviction faces murder charge in fatal motorcycle crash

Updated on: November 18, 2026 / 11:39 AM PST / CBS San Francisco

A suspected drunk driver involved in a San Jose crash that killed a motorcyclist over the weekend is facing a murder charge after previously being convicted of DUI, police said on Wednesday.

The crash happened on Saturday at about 8:43 p.m. in the area of McLaughlin Avenue and Bayard Drive, just west of U.S. Highway 101 and south of Interstate Highway 280/680.

In a press release, the San Jose Police Department said that a 2014 black Mercedes sedan was headed north on McLaughlin Avenue in the number two lane when it made a U-turn, going across the number one lane, at Bayard Drive. The car crossed directly in front of a motorcyclist who was also heading north on McLaughlin in the number one lane, who collided with the Mercedes, police said.

The man riding the motorcycle was pronounced dead at the scene, police said. The man driving the Mercedes and a woman who was a passenger in the vehicle were not hurt.

https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisc...aces-murder-charge-in-fatal-motorcycle-crash/


I normally don't post doom and gloom stuff like this. We've all been around the block with the potential dangers of riding so this isn't about that. Ok a tiny bit.

But the main thing that got my attention was this:

Officers determined the driver was under the influence of alcohol, and that he had a prior conviction for DUI, according to police. California law allows prosecutors to [charge] repeat DUI drivers with second-degree murder under what's known as a "Watson murder." Anyone convicted of a DUI is formally issued a Watson advisement by the judge that a subsequent DUI causing death can result in murder charges because of implied malice.

The Watson reference comes from a landmark 1981 California Supreme Court case involving Robert Allan Watson, convicted of second-degree murder for killing three people in a 1979 drunk driving crash in Redding.


I'd prefer to see shall instead of can.

I've seen cases where the circumstances of a collision were so egregious a DA charges murder. But I had no idea CA had a statue that is an If >Then law. There's no difference is a drunk killing a motorcyclist or someone in a car or a pedestrian. I'm not making the the case that killing a motorcyclist is a special circumstances crime. it's not.

But I'm encouraged to know that DUI drivers are being taken seriously as a danger to the public at large. There are still occasional news reports of a DUI driver killing someone after several DUI arrests and convictions and still in possession of a valid license.

It'll be some time before the court case is resolved. I hope there's no plea deal and the guy does some serious time. Second-degree murder doesn't necessarily deserve LWOP (sadly we have a moratorium on capital punishment) but 3-8 years (a WAG) would be woefully insufficient. Given that to a large degree convicts seldom serve the full bit I'd hope for 10+ so that he'd server at least 5. And no credit for time served. But that won't happen. /rant

What's on your docket?
 
Back
Top Bottom