Re: ST1100 Carb Sync - SK Flowmeter vs Mercury STicks
Here's another view on synchronizing carbs (below). I originally poSTed this to the old ST1100 email LiST. The only thing I'd add to it today is:
- if you use an SK single-handed, get a couple of 90? adapters or position a mirror so you can read the meter while turning the carb screws.
My dealer uses merc sticks and the Honda Service and Common manuals call for them. Measure the intake manifold vacuum or snorkle air flow, your choice... but I'll stick with my STicks, thanks.
IMHO, FWIW, YMMV yadda yadda.
Regards, John
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Subject:[ST-Riders] SK Flowmeter vs Carb Sticks Comparo
Date:9/1/2006 12:26:26 PM Central Daylight Time
From:STGhOOST@aol.com
To:st1100@st1100.com
--
Hello LiSTers,
As one of the very last things to do to get ready for WeSTOC, I just sync'd
The Grey GhOOST's carbs. My friend Bill Rankin had loaned me his new SK model
"STE Synchrometer Flow Meter" to try, so I decided compare it with my old
tried-n-true "Motion Pro Vacuum Carb Synchronizer."
Here's the short version: I'm keeping my mercury sticks.
Why? With the carb sticks I can sync the other 3 carbs' mercury vacuum
levels to within 2mm of the #4 base carb, sometimes all four dead-level. This
often requires almost imperceptable movement of the adjustment screws. Sync'g
with the flowmeter requires far more movement of the screw to get any change in
the meter reading and IMHO results in an imprecise 'tune' of the carbs. Let me
explain further...
Here's how I did my comparo. I performed my normal sync with the carb sticks
- removed tupperware until the fairing pockets were off, hooked up the carb
sticks (dunno why folks find this hard), start the engine and let it warm up,
adjust carbs to #4 IAW the manual. Gott'm within a whisker of each other...
bike sounds good. BTW, it was barely out of 'tune' since my last sync (#1: -
+3mm, #3: -5mm) some, what?...2 years and 8K ago.
Anyway, I then shut off the ST and removed the air cleaner cover. Restarting
the engine I notice the still hooked-up carb sticks show no appreciable
change... interesting. Then I measured all the carbs air inflow at the air horns
with the SK meter. They're all right at just under the #4 cylinder's reading
of "4" on the SK's scale. Cool... nothing wrong with my ole 'sticks.' ^)
However, [there's always a 'however', isn't there?] in the interest of a
thorough comparo, I then turned the #1 and #2 adjustment screws a good bit in
opposite directions and proceeded to do a sync with the SK meter. [the merc tubes
at this point were waaay outta 'sync'] At this point, the difference between
the two methods became apparent to me:
- the SK meter is far less sensitive to adjustment screw movement, taking
what in comparison to the merc sticks would be considered gross movement, just to
get the meter's red needle to move even its own width.
As a point of reference, at a reading of 3.5 on the SK, there's only one
needle width between there and the '4' on the scale. No wonder folks like this
method (measuring the air inflow instead of the intake vacuum) - readily turn
the adjustment screws a sixteenth or even an eighth of a turn and the SK will be
quite satisfied, showing the carbs "in sync" (while the mercury tubes at
those settings showed some cylinders as much as 3/4" off of #4).
BTW, turning the screws while trying to view the SK meter's needle is nearly
impossible as they point away from the side of the bike where that cylinder's
screw is located. Get a 90? attachment if you decide to go this route, or
plan on a trusted assistant to call out the numbers while you do the deed.
In fairness, I must say that at least subjectively, I only noticed a very
slight difference in the sound, or apparent 'smoothness,' of the engine with the
new SK tune compared to the carb sticks' state of tune/sync. Also, at this
point I didn't button up the GhOOST and go for a ride to see what the SK tune
felt like... not with the mercury tubes that far off. I put the air cleaner
cover back on, resync'd the carbs with the mercury tubes and called it done.
Anyway, if you're happy with your SK meter and your ST seems to run fine/up
to your expectations... fine. However, I'll stick with my old mercury tubes...
no need to change what ain't broke, IMHO. The SK is certainly portable, but
if you need to take one on the road with you because you have to resync
enroute, there's something wrong with your Honda.
BTW, I'm not totally unfamilar with flow meters, having used one for years
to sync the carbs on my 72 Jag XJ-6.
BTW2, I can ride my ST right after doing a carb sync. I just put on my old
pair of deerskin work gloves, remove the carb sticks' hoses and rehook the
cylinders' vac hoses. No burns. And timewise, using the SK or carb sticks is a
wash.
YMMV and probably will.
Just another data point...
Regards, John OoSTerhuis STOC 1058
http://community.webshots.com/user/stghoost
http://community.webshots.com/user/st1100greyghoost
http://community.webshots.com/user/stoc1058
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~