I bought a Shark Evoline 2 and I like it allot. I tried the Shoei because I really like their products as well. Both are reasonably light being that they are modulars; actually, I should say they are well balanced and I find that important.
I wear a different size in the modulars; that is because they use a different shell; just saying this so you don't assume you fit a Large in a Shark full face, you'll fit a large in the Evoline. I wear a large in full face ad Medium in Evoline.
I like the "double lock" feature of the chin bar, internal smoke visor that comes down enough. I also like the fact that it locks up in the fully open (sits behind the helmet, not way on top, catching wind) or closed positions. If you get a bit of fogging or require a bit more circulation, it has several locking (clicks) positions for the visor. Visors easy to operate with gloves on. If I could not have tried and found an Evoline, I was going for the Shoei.
What gives me so much faith in Shark is not only they are underrated on this side of the pond, they are one of the top picks in Europe... Most important is that a well fitting Shark helmet saved my life when I hit the moose with my head at 70 MPH...
Cannot stress enough that no matter what you pay or buy, it has to be well fitted. Most motorcycle shops I ran across do not know how to fit you, not all, but most. So, my advice would be to get knowledgeable about fitment, then, go try some helmets and remember to use that knowledge. Find your head type to determine which model conforms to that, operate the visors with gloves on, walk around with it on, get on a bike if you can, assume the riding positions, how is your visibility? etc...
The Shark or Shoei are over the mentioned budget; not a problem... Any helmet (DOT - Snell) that fits good, with features you can use and operate easily in your price range, is the one you should get. If you got a great deal on a top of the line helmet that is too large, remember that it can tear your head off in an accident; one that is too small, will make you uncomfortable, (diverts your attention from the task of riding), give you pain and headaches, etc.
If you intend to wear glasses under it, try it with glasses to check pressure points; if you will be listening to tunes, try it with your ear buds, etc...
This is just one guy's opinion, and according to Peppermint Patty, I should not leave the house without a helmet, ever...
Grizz