Your choice of course. But the first and third batteries you mentioned are what appear to be the long-lived OEM Yuasas and not the off the shelf replacement variety that doesn't seem to last as long as the first factory supplied battery - for a lot of members...
- 2005 Factory Yuasa, YTZ14S. $0.00
- 2009 Yuasa, YTZ14S. $0.00 previous owner
- 2014 Yuasa, YTZ14S. $65.00 I bought it off of Scott from Evapor when he was selling them off of new Honda generators.
I'm one of those members: The non-OEM Yuasa did NOT do well for me at all.